22 October 2010

When is yawning contagious?

ResearchBlogging.orgIt’s a little embarrassing.

Despite being about as familiar and as commonplace as you can get, we still don’t have a clear understanding of why humans yawn.

We know we start yawning early. We know we yawn when we’re tired. We know we yawn when we’re bored. And we know that yawning can sometimes be contagious. But the function, the why, has been elusive.

A new paper by Giganti and Zilli ties together a couple of yawning’s features: that the amount people yawn varies throughout the day, and that yawns can be contagious. But does the contagiousness of yawns vary throughout the day?

First, their got subjects to record their sleepiness and yawns over several days in a logbook. Now, self-report data always has concerns about accuracy (do people remember right, record immediately, or write things to make themselves look good), but because this is just baseline data on a fairly neutral subject, we’ll move on.

Second, they tested their subjects several times on a single day, showing them either people yawning or smiling, and recording the yawns generated in response.

Most of the results are not surprising. More yawns when people report their feeling sleeping. More yawns when people are shown pictures of yawns compared to smiles. The main finding of interest is that they claim there is a significant interaction between the time of day and how contagious yawns are.

Yawns are most contagious at 7:30 pm.

At every other time they tested during the day, the spontaneous yawns (determined from the logbook) were greater than the yawns triggered by the experimental stimulus of watching yawning people. Only in the early evening did the triggered yawns exceed the expected rate. They didn’t perform any post-hoc tests on their groups, however, so it’s not clear if any of the other four times had significantly more spontaneous yawning than induced yawning.

Interaction effects have a reputation as being unstable, so it would be very interesting to see these results replicated.

These results might nudge us a little closer to understanding why we yawn. The paper suggests there are at least two kinds of yawns. A spontaneous yawn and a yawn in a social setting may well be entirely different beasts that need different explanations. Maybe the reason yawns have thwarted our efforts to understand them is that a single explanation for yawns you make alone completely fail when you try to apply it to yawns you make around other people.

P.S.—Yawns during the writing of this post: At least three. I hope that if you yawn during this post, it’s a contagious yawn, and not one triggered by boredom!


Giganti F., & Zilli I. (2010). The daily time course of contagious and spontaneous yawning among humans Journal of Ethology. DOI: 10.1007/s10164-010-0242-0

Tiger photo by by Tambako the Jaguar on Flickr; baby photo by Twob on Flickr. Both used under a Creative Commons license.


Rob said...

I always thought that a yawn was a sort of "breath-reflex" to forcibly inhale some more oxygen. It seems to happen when your breathing is at its lowest (laying around, being tired, etc.).

Was there any measure of breath rate (eg. #inhale/min.)? I'm not sure about the contagious part (I heard elsewhere that it wasn't a significant effect), but the function of yawning seems to be a compensation for low breathrate.


Zen said...

No, the authors in this study didn't measure breathing rate.

The "more oxygen" hypothesis is commonly held, but one of the problems is related to this study: Why would seeing a yawn suddenly make you need more oxygen to trigger your own yawn?

From this paper:

"Greco et al. (1993) found that most of their survey respondents believed that too little oxygen or too much carbon dioxide were the main causes of yawning (i.e., the respiratory hypothesis). At best, the respiratory hypothesis is incomplete – for example, both boredom and seeing other people yawn are potent causes of yawning. Breathing faster or more deeply is a more effective way of increasing oxygen intake and expelling carbon dioxide than a single deep inspiration, especially since a period of apnea usually follows a yawn (Hauptmann, 1920; Lehman, 1979). Nevertheless, the hypothesis has been widely held since its mysterious origins in the 19th century (Dumpert, 1921). ...

"Periods of apnea are not followed by compensatory yawning after breathing is resumed, as the respiratory hypothesis would require. ...

"The clearest evidence against the respiratory hypothesis comes from a laboratory study by Provine, Tate, and Geldmacher (1987) in which subjects breathed air mixtures containing more than normal amounts of carbon dioxide (3%-5%); their rate of breathing increased but the frequency of yawning was unaffected. Exercise that doubled their rate of breathing also had no effect on subjects' yawning frequency. Conversely, subjects breathing pure oxygen did not show decreased yawning. It seems clear that yawning is something more than an odd kind of respiration."

Baenninger R. 1997. On yawning and its function.
Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
4(2): 198-207.

baillement said...

all you want to know about yawning can be read on http://yawning.info (english)
and in french

the book